Test setup
- 01The socket. The cable modem has a phone socket, like the one that used to be on the wall. That is all the provider hands out to private customers.
- 02The translator. A small box plugs into that socket and pretends to be a telephone. It picks up, dials and hangs up, and translates everything into network telephony.
- 03The system. A phone system runs on the router. Every phone in the house has its own extension, calls between them are free, calls to the outside go over the one landline.
- 04The phones. Two old analogue phones hang on the system through adapters, two mobiles through the app Linphone. To the system all four are simply extensions.
- 05The switchboard. Callers are greeted by the Nirus Laboratories: opening hours, a menu, hold music, voicemail. Before connecting, the switchboard asks whether the call may be used to train the in-house artificial intelligence. One for yes, zero for no. You are connected either way.
- 06Hanging up. A telephone has to notice when the other side hangs up. That is exactly what the line could not say. More on that below.
Effort
Two days. On the first, the landline worked after a few hours; the rest of the day went into the things you only notice once you make calls:
- The system refused to start at all unless a telephone by the same maker was in the house. It was persuaded.
- It believed it was a system in Germany. Every call went out with the German country code.
- The other side could not be heard. The sound was sent to an address where nobody was listening.
- The caller’s number was missing. It arrives after the first ring, and the translator picked up on the first.
- Every incoming call dropped after exactly 32 seconds. One single confirmation went to the wrong address, and the system waited exactly that long for it. It took a while to notice: every test call before had been shorter.
- The switchboard with its announcements and hold music. With an announcement every 45 seconds: “Patience is a measurable property.”
Hanging up
When a caller hung up, the line stayed busy. The switchboard kept talking, waited for a key, finally rang every phone in the house and in the end recorded a little melody on the voicemail. Meanwhile no other call got through.
The melody was the cause: four short tones, every 2.8 seconds. That was how the modem said “hung up”. The translator understands a break in the current, a reversed line voltage or a busy tone. It does not understand a melody.
- 01The stopgap. The lab wrote a small program that listens in on every call, looks for the four tones in the right order and hangs up on the second pass. It worked. It was in service for exactly one day.
- 02The call. Then the lab called the provider and asked for three things: a short break in the current on hang-up, a reversal of the line voltage and an ordinary busy tone instead of the melody. Engineering switched on all three the same day, as a trial.
- 03The test. Each of the three signals was tested on its own, then all together, incoming and outgoing, every call recorded. Two signals disconnect at once, the busy tone after about five seconds.
- 04The deviation. At first the busy tone was not recognised. So it was measured, 101 tone bursts long: it is a little higher and clearly faster than announced. With the measured values it works.
- 05The report. The provider received a test report with all results and the deviation. According to the provider, the change is to be rolled out to all customers.
Why?
Because the number is paid for either way. Because an old telephone that really rings is nicer than one on a shelf. Because it turned out that you can simply ask a provider. And because it can be done.
Test result
Passed. Calls come in, go out, and whoever hangs up has hung up. The listening program has retired.
On the side, the lab measured whether the translator is electrically matched to the line. Four settings, four calls: it already was.
Open: a locked iPhone does not ring yet. The app may not stay awake in the background, and the system maker’s own solution exists only in North America.